This $75 gift certificate gets you dinner for two at Gennaro Italian Restaurant. (taxes and gratuities are not included)

Zagat says it all... 

"Even though you might have to wait for a table (they don't take reservations), the food is consistently amazing - I've been going here for years. My favorites include the gnocchi, the lamb chops, and the penne."
Zagat 

665 Amsterdam Ave, between 92nd and 93rd Street