Winner receives a gift certificate for two dozen regular size cupcakes at Sibby's Cupcakery in San Mateo.  Gift certificate is not redeemable for cash.  Advance orders only - Limited availability, so place your phone order early (415) 613-4373 to ensure availability.  Open Tuesday-Sunday.  Delivery ($25, not included) or pick-up by appointment (they do not have a retail storefront).

Sibby's specializes in custom cupcakes made the old-fashioned way. Baked to order from scratch using only the finest ingredients, including fresh eggs, sweet cream butter from local dairy farms, Scharffen Berger chocolate and Nielsen-Massey pure Madagascar Bourbon vanilla.  No substitutes, no shortcuts.  With extra smiles on top.

Feast your eyes on some of the pictures included here.  Some of their favorites:

• Flavor of the Month for April: Totally Strawberry Strawberry cupcake. Strawberry frosting. Made with juicy organic strawberries. Totally yummy.


• Butter Cup Vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting


• Carrot Cinnamon Super-moist carrot cupcake with cinnamon cream cheese frosting


• Chocolate & Cream Rich chocolate cupcake with vanilla cream cheese frosting


• Choco Choco Rich chocolate cupcake with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting


• Chocolate Coconut Cream Rich chocolate cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and shredded coconut


• Coconut Snowball Coconut cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and shredded coconut


• Confetti Surprise Moist vanilla cupcake with confetti sprinkles baked inside, topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting


• Dulce de Leche Vanilla cupcake with dulce de leche filling (sweet, creamy caramel), topped with rich dulce de leche frosting


• Grandma's Chocolate Tea Cake Rich chocolate cupcake with cream cheese/chocolate chip center, topped with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting. Our most popular cupcake!


• Latte Love Vanilla cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting


• Lemon Drop Light lemon cupcake with fresh lemon buttercream frosting


• Mmm Good Mocha Rich chocolate cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting


• Red Velvet Classic Red Velvet cupcake with extra-rich cream cheese frosting


• Snickerdoodle Cinnamon sugar cupcake and cinnamon cream cheese frosting topped with sugar and spice and everything nice


• Super-Chewy Chocolate (Mini size only) Extra rich “brownie-like” chocolate cupcake with glossy dark chocolate frosting


• Sibby's Sampler Also known as the variety pack. Our sampler varies daily and includes an assortment of some of our favorite flavors. Sorry, we can’t guarantee specific flavors, but you'll always get a delicious mix!