Use the $50 gift certificate at M. Wells Steakhouse: 

A converted garage, M. Wells Steakhouse is a Michelin-starred restaurant featuring a trout tank, wood-burning grill, raw bar, dessert cart, boatyard private dining, an outdoor oven on the terrace and an adjacent Pétanque court.

If you don't already know, come find out why the NY Times says that Hugue Dufour's food is celebratory and "worth flying for."