Edgar’s Cafe sits nestled on West 84th Street and is one of the best kept secrets on the Upper West Side. The moment you arrive, it is evident who this cafe was named for; an oversized portrait of poet Edgar Allen Poe haunts the dining area, and as you gaze around this magical Mediterranean eatery, you immediately notice the vaulted ceiling, which was designed to appear as if it were on fire.

$25 gift certificate towards any breakfast, lunch, dinner, dessert or coffee.